Ask The Editors
Q:
I have to decide on a new pair of headphones. What's the difference between 'noise-isolating' and 'noise-cancelling' headphones?
Submitted by:
Luciana, via email
A:
Both 'noise-isolating' and 'noise-cancelling' headphones aim to reduce how much sound from the outside world gets into your ear and subtracts from your listening pleasure. The reason these technologies have different names is because they attack the problem of ambient noise in very different ways.
Noise-isolating headphones use a piece of thick foam around the earpiece to block out ambient noise before it enters the ear canal. The seal between your ear and the earpiece needs to be tight, so most companies ship earpieces of varying sizes for you to select the most comfortable one. These kinds of headphones can significantly improve your listening experience, require no batteries to function and usually cost less than noise-cancelling models.
Noise-cancelling headphones use electronics to filter out the surrounding noise. They have tiny microphones built inside them that sample the ambient noise, invert the sound waves and play them back alongside the music you're listening to. The natural ambient sound and the inverted ambient sound produced by the headphones cancel each other out, hence the name 'noise-cancelling'. They need to be powered by batteries.
We recommend you always test out the effectiveness of any possible purchase before you buy, and consult our reviews for the best advice on individual products -- our high-tech headphones round-up would be a good place to start.
Answer by:
Nate Lanxon
MP3 & Digital Music Editor
More Questions
Q&A: Which mobile phone for the gym?
I'm looking for a mobile phone that has a good MP3 player with a headphone socket, that I can use at the gym. I'd like a camera and Net access too -- is this too much to ask?
Q&A: How do I get a Nintendo Wii in time for Christmas?
I'm desperately trying to find a Nintendo Wii before Christmas -- do you know where I might be able to buy one?
Q&A: Can I afford a progressive scan camcorder?
Are there any affordable camcorders capable of recording progressive footage?
Q&A: Should I buy a camera or a camera phone?
Is it worth buying a compact digital camera now that the cameras in mobile phones are so good?
Q&A: Can camcorders take great stills?
Can camcorders take decent still photos?
Q&A: What HD disc player should I buy?
What kind of DVD player can you recommend for our LCD 1080p TV?
Q&A: How do I unlock the UK O2 iPhone?
How do I unlock the UK O2 iPhone?
Q&A: Where can I buy an iPhone?
Where can I buy an iPhone and how much is it going to cost in the UK?
Q&A: Can compact cameras zoom during video?
My compact camera won't zoom when I'm filming video. Are there any compacts out there that will?
Q&A: Should USB hard drives use mains electricity?
Should my USB hard drive be powered by the PC or by the mains?



